Justices said that Pennsylvania law gives the Department of Health broad authority to protect public health, but it doesn’t permit the department “to act by whim in all matters concerning disease” without specific regulations that empower a mask mandate.
HARRISBURG — The state Supreme Court on Thursday released its rationale for why it ruled that Gov. Tom Wolf’s administration had no legal authority to require masks in Pennsylvania’s schools and child care centers, even amid a pandemic and surging cases of COVID-19.
The Democratic-majority court ruled 6-0 on Dec. 10, immediately ending the statewide mask mandate, except in school districts that still required them. Justice Thomas Saylor did not participate in the decision.
The justices’ 58-page opinion released Thursday does not discuss whether school districts have the legal authority to require masks.
But the justices wrote that the Republican-controlled Legislature’s move in June to end Wolf’s COVID-19 emergency disaster declaration also eliminated any legal justification for a school mask mandate.
The justices note that state law gives the Department of Health broad authority to protect public health, but it doesn’t permit the department “to act by whim or fiat in all matters concerning disease” without specific regulations that empower a mask mandate, they wrote.
They also wrote that they doubted lawmakers intended to grant that sort of power in the law, given how many current regulations guide how the department exercises its authority.
Regulations under the state’s disease control law deal with quarantine and surveillance measures, but not a mask mandate that applies broadly and without a definite time limit, the justices wrote.
The lawsuit was filed by Senate President Pro Tempore Jake Corman (R-Centre); state Rep. Jesse Topper (R-Bedford); two religious schools; three public school districts; and several parents of schoolchildren.
Politics
100,000 PA residents to benefit from American Rescue Plan’s broadband expansion projects
The Shapiro administration announced earlier this month it is distributing $204 million from the American Rescue Plan for high-speed internet...
Central Pa. man found guilty of assaulting officers during Jan. 6 attack
Joseph Pastucci of Cumberland County stormed the U.S. Capitol with his wife, who kicked a Capitol Police officer in the groin as they were trying to...
Republicans’ Latino outreach offices missing in 2024
Republicans once looked at organizing in Pennsylvania’s Black and Latino communities, but now their presence is non-existent. While the Biden...
Local News
What do you know about Wawa? 7 fun facts about Pennsylvania’s beloved convenience store
Wawa has 60 years of Pennsylvania roots, and today the commonwealth’s largest private company has more than 1,000 locations along the east coast....
Conjoined twins from Berks County die at age 62
Conjoined twins Lori and George Schappell, who pursued separate careers, interests and relationships during lives that defied medical expectations,...