We found the 3 best pizza parlors in Scranton

A fresh slice of pepperoni and cheese pizza

Getty Images

By The Keystone Staff

May 22, 2024

If there’s one thing that unites people across all walks of life, it’s a love for pizza. Whether you prefer a classic cheese pie or like to experiment with unique toppings, there’s a pizza out there for everyone. In Scranton, pizza lovers are spoiled for choice with an array of pizzerias offering mouthwatering pies. Today, we’re here to share with you our top picks for the best pizza parlors in Scranton. Get ready to embark on a delicious journey through the city’s pizza scene!

1. Alfredo’s Cafe

1040 S Washington Ave

“Alfredo’s Pizza Cafe or Pizza by Alfredo’s?” That’s an important question for the folks on The Office, who know that Alfredo’s Cafe serves up the best pie in Scranton.

Nestled in the South Side Shopping Center, Alfredo’s is a beacon for those in pursuit of classic pizza perfection. This charming pizzeria has woven itself into the fabric of the city, becoming a cherished destination for pizza aficionados far and wide. At Alfredo’s, tradition is a promise. A promise to deliver slices drenched in authenticity and enveloped in the warmth of Italian hospitality.

Walking into Alfredo’s Cafe, you’re greeted by the aroma of bubbling cheese and tangy tomato sauce, a prelude to the feast that awaits. Whether you opt for Chicken BBQ Pizza or the Pizza Alfredo Plus, you’re sure to fall in love with Alfredo’s thick crusts and bubbling cheeses. One bite, and you’ll understand why Kevin takes the pizza selection so seriously.

In a city buzzing with culinary experimentation, Alfredo’s Cafe remains a haven for those seeking solace in the familiar comfort of a well-made pizza. It’s a place where time seems to slow down, inviting you to savor each slice, each moment, with genuine appreciation. Here, pizza is a narrative of family, tradition, and the simple pleasures of life.

As you settle into the cozy ambiance of Alfredo’s, you’ll find yourself among a community of loyal patrons, each with their own stories of memorable meals and moments shared over a pie from this esteemed pizzeria. It’s this sense of connection, fostered by shared plates and stories, that captures the essence of Alfredo’s Cafe.

2. Pizza by Pappas

303 N Washington Ave

In business since 1971, Pizza by Pappas has become a local legend. Their no-frills menu doesn’t offer an endless array of options. Instead, they keep it simple and execute to perfection.

There are just two specialties pies here, but they’re both masterpieces. The Pappas Special, loaded with five types of meat and a few veggies, is nothing short of a feast. And the Veggie Special is a colorful celebration of the bounty of the earth, each slice bursting with flavors.

The walls, adorned with local art and memorabilia, tell the story of Scranton’s vibrant community and the role this pizzeria plays within it. The staff, always friendly and welcoming, treat you like family from the moment you step inside, making your dining experience feel personal and cherished.

3. Samario’s

123 W Market St

Perhaps best known for serving the best cheesesteaks in Scranton, Samario’s is no stranger to the pizza game. This modern marvel of a pizzeria is where creativity meets crust, offering a menu that daringly deviates from the norm to introduce a fusion of flavors that tantalizes the taste buds and leaves diners craving for more. Samario’s is a testament to the adventurous spirit of pizza lovers everywhere, a place where curiosity is rewarded with the most delightful and unexpected combinations.

Embark on a flavor journey with Samario’s standout selections like Sammy’s Favorite, a recreation of Samario’s top-notch cheesesteak in pizza form. Or, if you’re a traditionalist, let the Margherita seduce you, with its fresh, fragrant basil. Each pie at Samario’s is a masterpiece, crafted with an artist’s touch and an innovator’s vision, ensuring that from the first bite to the last, your dining experience is nothing short of extraordinary.

Dining at Samario’s is an experience that extends beyond the palate. The modern, yet cozy atmosphere invites you to relax and enjoy the art of pizza making in a setting that’s as inviting as the food is innovative. Here, every meal is an opportunity to explore new tastes, engage with friends and family, and become part of a community that values exploration and excellence in equal measure.



Related Stories
Share This